Types of Players Every Pro Clubs Manager Deals With (and What to Do)

The Wannabe, the Toxic Star, the Tactician, the Lone Gunman: the player types every Pro Clubs captain meets, and how to handle each one. Updated for FC 27.

Updated 8 Oct 20268 min read
On this page15 sections
  1. The Wannabe
  2. The Toxic Star
  3. The Noisy Mic
  4. The Tactician
  5. The Show-off
  6. The Foreign One
  7. Someone’s Friend
  8. The Gang
  9. The Junior
  10. The Lone Gunman
  11. The Revolutionist
  12. New for FC 27: The Grounds Tourist
  13. Tips for any Clubs manager
  14. FAQ
  15. Sources

Run a Pro Clubs team for long enough and you’ll meet every one of these people. This piece was written by sunset_jack, a Pro Clubs manager with more than nine years in charge of squads when he wrote it, and it’s the most “that’s literally my club” article we’ve ever published. We’ve given it a light refresh for FC 27, but the players haven’t changed. They never do. We met plenty of them ourselves in the PRO11 league we ran from 2017 to 2019.

The Wannabe

Seen a few YouTube videos, drifted through a myriad of clubs, Mister Know-It-All, Seen-It-All. Knows everything about defending, attacking, skills, shots and dribbling. Says he can play any position. Instantly spots his teammates’ weaknesses and DMs the managers detailed advice on this and that. In FC 27 he’s watched every “best meta archetype” video and has a strong opinion on yours.

At the same time, his favorite button is Sprint, which he holds the whole match. He passes the ball the moment he gets it; forget build-up. He always remembers the goals he scored (not many, to be honest) and uses them to prove the value of his opinion.

Advice: release and forget.

The Toxic Star

The guy has skills. He knows how to pass and score and is mostly useful on the pitch. For the first few weeks he’s positive, energetic and cheerful. Then suddenly everything goes south: the passing is weak, the tactics are far from perfect, nobody passes to him. In his mind, anyway. The team is playing exactly the same game it played the day he joined.

It starts with sarcastic remarks, then open complaints in the team chat. Then come hours of conversations with the managers about how to change the fundamentals of the team, who to release immediately and who should get time to prove himself. And it drags on and on and on.

Advice: if he’s useful, spend some time in private talks keeping hope alive. If the rest of the team suffers, thank him for the effort and release him.

The Noisy Mic

The one with a constant soundtrack behind his voice channel. Screaming partner, music, broken dishes, howling animals: you name it. Distracts everyone on the pitch. Every goal is followed by a happy roar worthy of a South American commentator.

Advice: mute him for good. :D

The Tactician

Decent skill level, always looking for a better formation. Usually plays CDM or at the back. Does his (YouTube) research and always blames the formation for the team’s failures. He’s on a constant hunt for the perfect setup, which he loves to discuss with the managers: “If we switch to 4-3-3 and move this guy here and that guy there, we’ll be unstoppable!” In FC 27 he also has a spreadsheet of which archetype everyone should be playing.

To be fair, some of his ideas are quite decent. But the search never stops.

Advice: engage in the conversation and sometimes (SOMETIMES!) try his suggestions, ideally in friendlies or Drop In first. Point him at our attacking formations and defensive formations guides and let him do the reading.

The Show-off

Born for glory. In one match he dribbles about 32,798,427 times. If it’s a pass, it’s a rabona. If it’s a shot, it’s a scorpion or a backheel. When your team attacks, he’ll try five to seven skill moves before passing. One-on-one with the keeper? He has to dribble round him, not just score. Oh, and don’t forget the afro haircut. These days he’s a Magician or Spark with Trickster, and he’s very proud of it.

He ignores every request to be more team-oriented.

Advice: these players don’t stay in a club for long. Give it some time and the situation will sort itself out.

The Foreign One

Always in the chat, party or lobby, but his vocabulary is “hi”, “bye”, “thanks”, “ok”. Comes and goes without introductions. Might be useful on the pitch, but he’s really hard to communicate with, mostly because of the language difference. With crossplay across PS5, Xbox and PC, you’ll meet more of him than ever. Might leave the club without notice.

Advice: Google Translate him and get him into the conversation. :)

Someone’s Friend

“Hey mate, listen, I’ve got a friend who wants to join. He’s top. Scores, passes.” How many times have you had that conversation? You give it the green light, and suddenly someone joins who basically can’t do anything. Random positioning, passes only to his friend, constantly losing the ball. Now you have a dilemma: kick him straight away and risk losing both friends, or try to make something out of him.

Advice: in FC 27, try him in Rush or Drop In first, before he gets a league spot. If it doesn’t work, remove him, but explain why to the person who brought him in before you do.

The Gang

Speaking of friends. At some point you might have three, four or five friends playing in your club. They know each other, get noisy on the mic and share things only they care about. It’s the same on the pitch: they get results with decent chemistry, but it’s a team within a team, because they mostly pass to each other. As soon as you criticize one of them, they team up against you, politely or even aggressively. “Hey man, it wasn’t his fault he missed the 1v1. The pass from that other guy was awful.” Sound familiar?

Advice: there’s always a leader in the gang, so talk to him one-on-one and explain the issues. There’s a real risk the whole gang leaves, but… well… guests come and go, the hotel stays.

The Junior

“OMG I’m top and whatever.” Usually 14 to 17 (says he’s at least 18, though), super enthusiastic both in chat and on the pitch. Always has crazy ideas: “Let’s start our YouTube channel!!! Better yet, an Insta with screenshots of our games!!! Let’s enter every tournament we can find!!!!!” That kind of enthusiasm, which never turns into anything feasible. In the team he’s treated like a Padawan and is the subject of numerous jokes.

To be fair, some of these younglings do have skills and can be shaped into something decent.

Advice: if he performs well on the pitch, do some parenting and help him grow. Otherwise, remove him gently and with a proper explanation.

The Lone Gunman

These guys mostly play ST, usually as a Finisher. They have a godlike level of skill and can bring really good stats to your team. Pass him the ball and he’ll create a goal out of nothing: a crazy solo run or a 40-meter screamer. The only thing you can’t get from him is commitment. He knows what he wants from the game and drifts between clubs and Drop In lobbies, coming and going as he pleases.

That can hurt team morale when someone joins for a few games, automatically gets the ST spot (which, honestly, his skill deserves) and then leaves again.

Advice: useful as they are, you can’t stop these guys from leaving. They’re usually looking for two things: competition and good communication. Give them both and they might stay a bit longer.

The Revolutionist

Ah, my favorite. So many sweet memories. :D Usually a guy with a decent skill level. Polite. Educated. As long as you agree on the team’s vision, tactics and roster, he can be Santa’s Little Helper: cheering people up and giving good advice. The moment you suggest something that doesn’t fit his worldview, you’ve got yourself a rebel.

Smart enough not to oppose you directly, he builds a coalition instead. He shares his own well-worded vision of how the team should ACTUALLY evolve and what everyone should do to reach a state of Zen. Basically, a club manager in disguise.

Advice: listen, take it in, exchange opinions, but stand your ground. Eventually he’ll leave, and (inevitably) take a few members with him.

New for FC 27: The Grounds Tourist

Clubs now lives inside The Grounds, a shared world for up to 100 players with small-sided pitches and Kickabouts like Bucket Ball, Balloon Ball and The Big Race. And so a new type was born. He’s online every night. He’s just never in the stadium. League match at nine? He’s in a Rush game on a dirt pitch across town, or three rounds deep in Bocce Ball, and he’ll be “there in two minutes” for the next twenty.

The good news: everything he does in The Grounds still earns Archetype XP, so he turns up to the next match a few levels higher.

Advice: set a fixed match time and a meeting point, and make it clear that league games come first. If he keeps missing them, he’s not a Clubs player, he’s a Grounds player, and that’s fine too. Just not in your starting XI.

Tips for any Clubs manager

  1. 01
    Set expectations on day one. Match times, positions and how you pick the team. Most drama starts with a rule nobody wrote down.
  2. 02
    Talk in private, praise in public. Almost every type above gets worse when you call them out in the team chat.
  3. 03
    Use Drop In and Rush as trials. In FC 27 you can test new players without giving away a league spot.
  4. 04
    Accept that people leave. Guests come and go, the hotel stays.

Ready to organize more than one club? Here’s how to run a Pro Clubs league, with what we learned running PRO11.

Of course, there are more types out there; these are just the ones we’ve met the most. Which one are you? And which one is your manager? Have fun managing. :)

FAQ

Do you need a full team to play Clubs in FC 27?

No. EA says players “no longer need a handful of online Clubmates to enjoy Clubs”. Stadium Drop In matches you into 11v11 or Rush games, and you can play small-sided matches around The Grounds.

How do I find players for my Pro Clubs team?

Play Drop In and Rush, and invite the people who pass to you and talk on the mic. Clubs communities on Discord and Reddit help too; here’s where to find players for your club. Trial new players in Rush before you give them a league spot.

What’s the hardest player type to manage?

In our experience, the Revolutionist and the Toxic Star: they’re good enough that you want to keep them, and they can split the dressing room.

Sources

Checked on 8 October 2026: